NFC (Contactless) Payment, vs QR Code Payment; Which One is Better?


Pebl Team
June 21, 2024

In today's fast-paced world, contactless payments have become increasingly popular, changing the way we conduct transactions. The rise of digital wallets has brought both NFC (Near Field Communication) and QR code payments into the spotlight, sparking a debate on which method is more effective.

While both options offer convenience and security, they serve different purposes and situations. NFC payments are supported by financial institutions and seamlessly integrate with digital wallets such as Apple Pay and Google Pay. On the other hand, QR codes provide a cost-effective and easily accessible alternative.

This article delves into the applications, benefits, and limitations of NFC and QR code payments to help businesses and consumers make informed choices.

Interested in what we’re saying?


What Are NFC Payments Used For?

NFC (Near Field Communication) payments have become integral to consumer experiences, especially in developed countries. Primarily utilized for point of sale (POS) transactions, NFC technology enables consumers to make secure purchases with a simple tap of their smartphone or contactless card. This method is commonly found in settings like supermarkets, boutiques, fast food outlets, and vending machines.

NFC payments have brought about significant changes in public transportation. Many urban transit systems now offer NFC-enabled payment systems, allowing commuters to pay for their rides effortlessly without the need for tickets or cards. Cities like London and New York have embraced NFC payment options in their public transport networks, streamlining the commuting experience.

Furthermore, the banking and financial sectors have made substantial investments in NFC technology to improve transaction security and convenience. Popular platforms such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Samsung Pay have been widely adopted, enabling millions of customers to store their credit card details on their smartphones. This integration not only speeds up the checkout process but also incorporates robust security measures like tokenization and biometric authentication to protect sensitive financial data.

Despite the costs involved for merchants using NFC-enabled terminals and the necessity for consumers to possess compatible devices, advancements like SoftPOS—enabling NFC payments through secure smartphone applications—have helped alleviate some of these challenges. These developments are making NFC payments more accessible to businesses.

Both technologies have their strengths and can work together well to give customers lots of payment options. It’s about aligning your choice with your business goals, budget limits, and what your customers prefer.

What Are Some Disadvantages Associated with NFC Payments?

While Near Field Communication (NFC) payments offer a secure way to conduct transactions, they do come with limitations. One major drawback of NFC payments is the investment required by merchants. The cost of setting up NFC-enabled payment terminals can be prohibitively high for small businesses and entrepreneurs. This expense encompasses not only the hardware itself but ongoing maintenance and the possibility of software upgrades, which can place a significant financial strain.

Although NFC payments are generally considered secure, there are lingering security concerns such as the risk of RFID/NFC skimming. Unauthorised individuals armed with NFC readers could potentially intercept data from cards or devices if they come into proximity, presenting a security threat despite the utilisation of advanced encryption methods.

What Are QR Code Payments Typically Used For?

QR (Quick Response) code payments have emerged as a cost-efficient means to conduct transactions in environments where cost-effectiveness and ease of implementation are key factors. Initially introduced as a technology to facilitate payments, QR codes have transitioned into a mainstream payment option with diverse applications.

Within the retail industry, QR code payments find use in both physical store transactions and online purchases. Customers have the option to scan a QR code displayed on the checkout counter using their smartphone's camera to make payments from their mobile wallet applications. This approach is quite popular in places like China, where platforms such as WeChat Pay and Alipay have made QR code transactions commonplace. In e-commerce, websites utilize QR codes, allowing shoppers to scan and pay without having to input payment information.

Another notable application of QR code payments is for peer-to-peer (P2P) transactions. By scanning a QR code, individuals can easily transfer money to friends or family members, streamlining P2P payments. This feature is especially beneficial in regions with high mobile phone usage but limited traditional banking access.

Furthermore, QR codes have carved out a space in the nonprofit sector for fundraising and donations. Charitable organizations can showcase QR codes on their materials, enabling donors to contribute instantly through mobile payment platforms. This method simplifies the donation process and broadens its accessibility.

What Are Some Drawbacks of Using QR Code Payments?

While these transactions offer advantages like cost-effectiveness and straightforward implementation, they also come with limitations. One notable downside of using QR code payments is the risk of security issues. QR codes can be easily manipulated for malicious intents, like phishing and hacking. For instance, cybercriminals could swap QR codes with ones leading users to deceitful websites or capturing sensitive data. This highlights the importance for both customers and merchants to exercise caution when creating and scanning QR codes, as a single compromised code could result in harm.

While QR code payments are relatively straightforward to use, they still necessitate an understanding of technology from the user’s end. Individuals must be familiar with scanning QR codes using their smartphone cameras and conducting transactions through their mobile wallet applications. This requirement might pose a challenge for those who are less tech-savvy or within demographics that have limited exposure to smartphone technology.

In contrast to NFC payments, which can occasionally process transactions offline and sync later, QR code payments typically demand real-time internet verification. This implies that they are ineffective in situations where offline transactions are required or when internet connectivity is unreliable.